Thursday, 30 January 2025

Pilgrimage: the eyes of all who see me.

On pilgrimage with Rabbi Neil


Friendship is a kind of pilgrimage and in recent years it's a pilgrimage I've been privileged to begin with Rabbi Neil Janes from South Bucks Jewish Community. I asked Neil if he would share some thoughts on pilgrimage. While you're reading that I'll start putting on various layers of Lycra and Gore-tex and get ready for the first day of this pilgrimage to Iona.






Rabbi Neil writes:
There is a phrase in one of the preparatory morning prayers recited by Jews which reads:

“Let me find grace, kindness, and compassion in Your eyes and in the eyes of all who see me”

The prayer is almost the last of the preparatory prayers before a person might leave home for the morning and join a community in prayer. It is one of my favourite prayers in the litany of prayers at the start of a morning service because it speaks powerfully of a desire to stay clear of evil ideas and people and to cleave to good deeds for the day. There have been times in my life when I’ve felt scared or anxious about what or who I might meet in the day and this prayer always steadied my resolve to meet all of the days challenges.

Until writing for my friend Father Stuart, as he embarks on his pilgrimage, I had not made the connection that the phrase I quote above is also found in the prayer recited by a Jew whenever embarking on a journey.

Every morning, the moment we step outside our house is a journey full of trepidation and opportunity. And let’s face it, Jews are all too familiar with leaving home under duress for journeys not of their own making. It’s no wonder then that we pray to be bestowed with grace, kindness and compassion in God’s eyes and in the eyes of all who see us.

I do think that prayer is best when it is subversive, challenging, suggesting a world that is not only made different through the hand of God but in our actions. I wonder what kind of a world we would live in if it were indeed filled only with people seeking grace, kindness and compassion from others and, because of this desire, they bestowed it on those around them?

A stanza in the poetry collection by Yehuda Amichai entitled ‘Open Closed Open’ reads:

I want a God who is seen and not who sees, who I am able to lead

And to tell him what he does not see. I want

A God who is seen and who sees. I want to see

How he covers his eyes, like a child playing blindman’s bluff.

 

It was the idea of being in the “eyes of God and those who see me” that really struck me in this prayer for a journey. It reminded me of the verse in the book of Exodus which describes the purpose of a pilgrimage:

“Three times a year all your males shall appear before the Sovereign, Eternal One.” (Exodus 23:17)

This is the foundation of what the rabbis of antiquity called ‘Re’iyah’ – appearing. ‘Re’iyah’ is the commandment at the heart of the ancient pilgrimage to the Temple in Jerusalem - to appear before God on the Jewish festivals of Passover (Pesach), Pentecost (Shavuot) and Tabernacles (Sukkot). The heart of a pilgrimage was to be seen by God. What a marvellously challenging idea – to go to a place to be seen by God. God is without beginning and without end, with no form and beyond our comprehension, yet here we are hoping to be seen…and isn’t God omnipotent and omnipresent? Can we not be seen by God anywhere, at any time, not just in the Temple in Jerusalem on the three pilgrimage festivals?

From this point, the rabbinic sages of the Talmud reflect on a painful theological question – a question at the heart of exile: since the Temple was destroyed in 70 CE by Rome, could it be that God’s face is hidden from us and we might never be ‘seen’? This is, after all, what Deuteronomy 31:17 suggests, “I will hide my face from them.” We have many sophisticated answers for the difficulties in life but nothing really fully explains the unspeakable pain and distress from which so many people suffer and their anguish in trying to understand ‘why’ life is as it is. And the agony of absence is the heart of God’s hidden face.

I personally find the pilgrimage through the partially navigated world of texts offers me a spiritual encounter, if not answers. This is the classical response to the dilemma of find a place to encounter God. The Jewish pilgrimage begins to take place in texts not in places. Indeed, the journey into the Torah, learning together as a community, even for one day is considered by the sages of the Talmud to be equivalent to the one day of ‘appearing’ before God in the Temple. But there’s something upturned in this encounter – for where I might think I am ‘seeing’ the traces of the Divine in our texts, the original pilgrimage was for God to see me. What must it have felt like to sense the spotlight of scrutiny in appearing before God?

Remarkably, there is quite a radical story described in the Talmud of Rabbi Judah Hanasi and Rabbi Hiyya who go to visit a blind sage. In their visit, the sages are told they receive a blessing, “You who have received the face of one who is seen and who does not see, may you be worthy to receive the face of the one who sees and is not seen.” (Babylonian Talmud, Chagigah, 5b) This complicated moment suggests something about human relationships and paying a visit to a friend or scholar can also become a pilgrimage of sorts.

The most profound experience at prayer for me was when a dear congregant whose wife had just died and wanted to sit next to me in a Sabbath morning service. In the stillness of space and in the timeless quiet of a synagogue service, I felt the presence of God’s grace and compassion envelop us.

Perhaps unsatisfied with the pilgrimage into text or to visit a sage or friend, yet another story by the rabbis some 1900 years ago tells how we must interpret signs in the world of the hidden presence of God. Rabbi Joshua ben Hananya is described as reading the hand gestures of a disputant in the court of Caesar. God may be hidden from us but, Rabbi Joshua understands, the Divine ‘hand is str
etched out over us’. In the absence of direct revelation or speech, we must become quite literally the ‘diviners’ of God’s presence. I love this story because it suggests the possibility of being seen is always present, we just have to notice and learn the vocabulary, the ‘code’ if you like. It’s almost as if we’re looking at shadow puppets and have to work out that God’s hand is stretched out over us, cradling us in the protective shelter of God’s care.

Perhaps we cannot be seen, for Jews maybe that is the meaning of the exile in which we find ourselves. Which makes me think: in the grace, kindness and compassion we encounter along the way and the acts of the same which we do to others – perhaps that is the closest we can get to being cradled in the hand of God. And then, maybe we go on a pilgrimage to help sharpen our senses to God’s presence or at least the intimation of God peeking out from behind the clouds.

So we pray, we study and even in our trepidation at the coming day we seek to treat each other with grace, kindness and compassion because after all, isn’t that what we seek for ourselves?


No comments:

Post a Comment

The Pilgrimage Begins: of Celts and their jewellery

From this bank of Gartan Lough Day 1:  Letterkenny to Gartan Lough and back. Distance: 19.2 miles (19.2 total) Total ascent: 1952 ft Time: 7...